Pointless rewrite? Probably.

Posted by chetan on August 06, 2008 in development, philosophy, software, work

Del.icio.us (sorry, it’s just plain old “Delicious” now) 2.0 finally launched a few days ago and the response so far has been mixed. But now that the dust has settled some, it’s time to think about just how we got here and if it was really worth all the trouble.

According to the official blog post, the new and improved Delicious brings us speed, usability, and oh so good looks among other features and it was a long time in the making. The Yahoo acquisition was announced on Dec 9, 2005 and the new site finally went live a little over two and a half years later on July 31, 2008. So why did it take them so long?

A key change as a result of the Yahoo! acquisition was their decision to rewrite the whole thing in PHP using the Symfony framework, for no other reason than that it’s the current corporate standard at Yahoo!. Oh, and, coincidentally, Yahoo! Bookmarks was also built on PHP+Symfony.

So now it starts to make a bit of sense: you take a system being actively used by millions of users around the world and you start over from scratch with the goal of building it bigger and better, toss in a couple of hot buzzwords to meet Web 2.0 compliance guidelines, and before you know it 2 years have gone by.

I find it very hard to believe that with all the talent and the thousands of man years combined software development experience over there, that no one understands the pros and cons of rewriting vs refactoring a code base, especially given the enormous success of the service and the relatively trouble-free history as compared to, say, Twitter.

At the same time, I understand it all too well. From where I sit, and having been involved in a similar situation in the past as well as with my current employer, the decision to move to PHP was clearly not based on a cost/benefit analysis of maintaing the current system. In fact, I wonder if they even understood what the real problems, if any, were with the existing system before deciding to not just rewrite it, but write it in another language.

Moving to another language is a pretty drastic step to take and will rarely solve your problem.


Leave a response

  1. Andreas Stephan Wed, 13 Aug 2008 10:48:26 EDT

    I agree, that rewriting the whole thing is a drastic measure. But YAHOO has the developer power to do it. Moreover, what I find more important is the outcome, which I really like by now after getting used to it. What was delicious running on before?

  2. chetan Wed, 13 Aug 2008 14:38:17 EDT

    I looked for information about their original platform but couldn’t find anything.

  3. chetan Fri, 22 Aug 2008 14:45:17 EDT

    Seems it was Perl for the frontend and C++ on the middle/back-end.

    http://tinyurl.com/653eg2 (reddit)